Switzerland : losses jobs and cost reductions for SBB
12/11/2015

Swiss Federal Railways (SBB) has launched the plan RailFit 20/30 to address expected increases in the cost of operating its rail network, by cutting expenditure of his maintenance by SFr 550m by 2020 and SFr 1.75bn by 2030. To calculate the savings potential, the SBB take the help of the consulting firm McKinsey. The railway company is likely to cut 900 jobs on the 28,000 jobs currently managed in the group. In a statement, Swiss Federal Railways said the measures were “a response to the large increase in costs of the rail system as the costs of other modes of transport experience a marked decrease”. The overall cost of the Swiss rail system is expected to rise sharply until 2030, it said, and as a result that SBB must take steps to remain competitive.

In last September, the Federal Council made known that SBB will have to cover themselves incremental costs of the railway infrastructure in 2016. Indeed, the budget increase of SFr 100 to 130 million francs required by the Federal Railways falls overboard. And nothing is expected for the coming years.

The reason? The resources of the Rail Infrastructure Fund (BIF) appear lower than expected and will not be sufficient. The availability of these means was a "sine qua non" by the DETEC (Ministery of Transport) to increase public subsidies to the SBB. Other reason: the fall of costs of the other transport modes.

(photo SBB)
The plan RailFit 20/30 includes cuts to general overheads, administration and distribution costs. According Andreas Meyer, the cost-cutting will not come at the cost of customer satisfaction, safety and quality but by making better use of new technologies and automation. “An additional reduction (of jobs after 2020) is likely to be needed," said the CEO of SBB.

As report International Railway Journal, with only moderate or minor increases in fares possible, RailFit20/30 will look at cutting costs in all areas and will review current service and operational concepts, including increasing the utilisation of SBB's train fleet. That reminds the Ouigo SNCF concept, where TGV trainsets are used twice more than the normal time. This can require a profound change in the maintenance of rolling stock, and therefore of the workshops.

This plan, unique in Switzerland, demonstrates the importance of the railway infrastructure and especially its cost-efficiency. This phenomenon is general in Europe while some commentators claimed that rail liberalization had resulted in increased public subsidies. In reality, this is not the liberalization that has put the costs on the rise, but well the minimum investment in infrastructure which requires today a radical rehabilitation. It's not only in Switzerland that it's sounding the alarm. The phenomenon has become serious in France and is taken very seriously in Germany. In Belgium, the CEO of SNCB is doing the exact opposite and does not want that the state gives billions to the network manager (Infrabel). He judges that the network manager must to make, alone, the savings imposed by Belgian government.

It is interesting to note that the best railway model in the world, is also facing to the same causes and the same consequences. Public subsidies have a political and a logical limit. This demonstrates the reality of the railway : a fantastic technology but not really cheap...